Business & Compliance
Dormant Company vs Active Company: Legal Differences In India
1.1. 1. What Is a Dormant Company?
1.2. 2. What Is an Active Company?
2. Dormant Company vs Active Company: Key Legal Differences 3. When Should a Company Choose Dormant Status? 4. What Are the Compliance Requirements for Dormant and Active Companies?4.1. Compliance Requirements for Dormant Companies
4.2. Compliance Requirements for Active Companies
5. Can a Dormant Company Conduct Business or Earn Revenue?5.1. Which Transactions Are Allowed?
5.2. Which Transactions Are Not Allowed?
5.3. The Mandatory Seven-Day Conversion Rule
5.4. What Happens If a Dormant Company Conducts Unauthorised Business?
6. How Can a Dormant Company Become an Active Company? 7. What Happens If a Dormant Company Fails to Meet Its Compliance Requirements? 8. ConclusionUnder the Companies Act, 2013, dormant status is a separate legal status. A company must apply to the Registrar of Companies (ROC) and receive formal approval before it can be treated as dormant. Until then, it generally continues to be classified as an active company, even if it has not carried out any business for several years.
In this article, we explain the difference between dormant and active companies in India, their legal requirements, compliance duties, permitted activities, conversion process, and the consequences of non-compliance.
What Is the Difference Between a Dormant Company and an Active Company?
The Companies Act, 2013, provides the legal framework for understanding both types of companies.
1. What Is a Dormant Company?
A dormant company is a company that has formally received dormant status from the Registrar of Companies under Section 455 of the Companies Act, 2013. A company can apply for dormant status if it meets either of the following conditions:
- It has been formed and registered for a future project or to hold an asset or intellectual property, and it does not carry out significant accounting transactions.
- It qualifies as an inactive company under the Act.
The law also explains what an inactive company means. A company can fall into this category if it:
- Has not carried on any business or operations.
- Has not made any significant accounting transaction during the last two financial years.
- Has not filed its financial statements and annual returns during the last two financial years.
However, there is an important difference between an inactive company and a dormant company. A company does not receive dormant status simply because it stops doing business. It must submit an application to the ROC and obtain approval. The ROC grants this status through a certificate issued in Form MSC-2.
2. What Is an Active Company?
An active company is a registered company that continues to operate under its regular legal status. It has the legal ability to carry out business activities, enter into commercial agreements, sell products, provide services, hire employees, earn revenue, and manage its daily operations.
An active company can be profitable or can be facing financial difficulties. It can also have no revenue for a particular year or can temporarily stop its business activities. However, these circumstances do not automatically change its legal status.
Dormant Company vs Active Company: Key Legal Differences
Basis | Dormant Company | Active Company |
|---|---|---|
Legal status | Receives formal dormant status from the ROC under Section 455. | Continues under its regular registered status. |
Business operations | Cannot carry on regular commercial business activities. | Can conduct normal business and commercial activities. |
Main purpose | Holding assets or intellectual property, preserving corporate identity, or preparing for a future project. | Carrying out trade, services, manufacturing, or other business operations. |
ROC compliance | Follows a simplified compliance framework under the Companies (Miscellaneous) Rules, 2014. | Follows the regular requirements under the Companies Act, 2013. |
Annual filings | Files Form MSC-3 within 30 days from the end of the financial year. | Files Form AOC-4 and Form MGT-7 or MGT-7A, as applicable. |
Audit requirements | Follows the applicable dormant-company accounting and audit requirements. | Follows regular statutory audit requirements under Section 139. |
Minimum directors | 3 for a public company, 2 for a private company, and 1 for an OPC. | 3 for a public company, 2 for a private company, and 1 for an OPC. |
Returning to operations | Must apply for active status through Form MSC-4. | Can continue or change its business activities under its active status, subject to applicable law. |
When Should a Company Choose Dormant Status?
Dormant status can be useful when business owners want to keep a company registered but do not currently need to run regular business operations.
- Holding a Brand, Patent, or Other Intellectual Property
Many startups and established businesses create separate companies to own intellectual property. This can include trademarks, patents, copyrights, software code, and other valuable rights. For example, a startup can register a company to own the software and brand name for a product that is still under development. The commercial launch can take another year or more.
- Preparing for a Future Project or Asset Purchase
Businesses sometimes incorporate a company well before the actual project begins. For example, promoters can create a company for a future real estate development, infrastructure project, renewable energy venture, or machinery purchase. The company can need time to obtain government approvals, permits, licences, funding, or land.
- Temporarily Pausing Business Activities
A company can decide to stop operations for some time because of market conditions, supply chain problems, financial difficulties, restructuring, or changes in management. The founders can still want to restart the business later. In such cases, dormant status can be worth considering, provided the company satisfies the eligibility requirements.
- Keeping the Company Without Closing It
Building a company takes time and effort. Promoters can have already secured a business name, developed a brand, acquired assets, or created a corporate structure for future use. If they do not want to permanently close the company, dormant status offers another option.
- Reducing Compliance Costs
Active companies must meet several annual legal and administrative requirements. These can involve audit fees, professional charges, annual filings, board meetings, and other compliance expenses.
What Are the Compliance Requirements for Dormant and Active Companies?
The Companies (Miscellaneous) Rules, 2014, provide the main compliance framework for dormant companies.
Compliance Requirements for Dormant Companies
A dormant company must follow the following requirements:
- File Form MSC-3 every year: A dormant company must file its annual return in Form MSC-3 within 30 days from the end of each financial year. This generally means filing it by April 30.
- Pay the prescribed annual fees: The company must pay the applicable fees under the Companies (Registration Offices and Fees) Rules, 2014.
- Maintain the minimum number of directors: Dormant status does not remove the minimum director requirements under Section 149 of the Companies Act, 2013.
- Hold Board Meetings: A dormant company must hold at least one Board Meeting in each half of a calendar year. The gap between the two meetings must not be less than 90 days.
- Report changes in directors and share capital: If there is a change in the company's directors or an allotment of securities, the company must complete the applicable ROC filings.
- Maintain statutory registers and records: The company must maintain the required statutory registers, books of account, and corporate records under the applicable provisions, including Section 128.
Compliance Requirements for Active Companies
Active companies have a wider range of statutory responsibilities because they can carry out regular commercial operations. Some of their main compliance requirements include:
- Annual financial statements and returns: An active company must file its financial statements in Form AOC-4 under Section 137 and its annual return in Form MGT-7 or MGT-7A, as applicable, under Section 92.
- Statutory audit: The company must appoint an auditor as required under Section 139. It must also prepare financial statements in accordance with the applicable provisions, including Section 129.
- Board and general meetings: An active company generally needs to hold at least four Board Meetings each year, with no more than 120 days between two consecutive meetings, subject to applicable exemptions.
- Tax and other statutory compliance: Depending on its activities and registrations, an active company can need to:
- File income tax returns.
- Complete GST returns and related requirements.
- Make applicable Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) filings.
- Follow labour laws relating to Provident Fund (PF), Employees' State Insurance (ESI), and Professional Tax.
- Event-based filings: The company must report relevant changes to the MCA. These can include changes in the registered office, share capital, charges, or constitutional documents such as the Memorandum of Association (MOA) and Articles of Association (AOA).
Can a Dormant Company Conduct Business or Earn Revenue?
Generally, no. A dormant company cannot continue regular commercial operations in the same way as an active company. Section 455 distinguishes significant accounting transactions from certain permitted transactions.
Which Transactions Are Allowed?
Under Section 455(2), certain transactions are excluded from the definition of significant accounting transactions. These include:
- Payments made by the company to the Registrar of Companies as statutory fees.
- Payments made to meet requirements under the Companies Act, 2013, or other applicable laws.
- Allotment of shares to meet the requirements of the Act.
- Payments for maintaining the company's registered office and statutory records.
Which Transactions Are Not Allowed?
Transactions outside the permitted categories can affect the company's eligibility to remain dormant. Examples include:
- Raising invoices for customers.
- Receiving payments for commercial services.
- Selling products or inventory.
- Purchasing goods for regular business operations.
- Taking commercial loans for business activities.
- Entering into ordinary trade or commercial contracts.
The Mandatory Seven-Day Conversion Rule
Under Rule 8(3) of the Companies (Miscellaneous) Rules, 2014, if a dormant company carries out an activity or experiences a change that affects its eligibility for dormant status, it must apply to return to active status within seven days of the relevant event.
What Happens If a Dormant Company Conducts Unauthorised Business?
If the ROC has reason to believe that a dormant company is secretly carrying out business or earning unauthorised revenue, it can take regulatory action. The Registrar can:
- Start an inquiry into the company's activities.
- Direct the company to change its status from dormant to active.
- Take action against the company and its officers for violations of the Companies Act and applicable rules.
How Can a Dormant Company Become an Active Company?
A company can decide to restart its business when its project is ready, market conditions improve, or it wants to use its assets commercially. The process under Section 455(5) and the Companies (Miscellaneous) Rules, 2014, generally involves the following steps.
- Obtain Board Approval: The company should hold a Board Meeting and pass a resolution approving the change from dormant to active status.
- Prepare the Financial Information: The company should prepare an updated statement of financial position and review its annual compliance records for the relevant period.
- File Form MSC-3: The company must file its annual return in Form MSC-3 for the relevant financial year up to the date of the application for active status, as required.
- Submit Form MSC-4: The company must file Form MSC-4 with the ROC and pay the prescribed fee under the Companies (Registration Offices and Fees) Rules, 2014.
- ROC Verification: The ROC reviews the application and checks whether the company has met the applicable statutory requirements.
- Receive Form MSC-5: If the ROC approves the application, it issues a certificate in Form MSC-5.
- Resume Regular Compliance and Operations: After receiving active status, the company can restart its commercial activities.
What Happens If a Dormant Company Fails to Meet Its Compliance Requirements?
Dormant status reduces certain compliance obligations, but directors cannot ignore the company completely. Failure to meet the applicable requirements can result in regulatory action.
- Loss of Dormant Status: A dormant company must file Form MSC-3 within the prescribed period. If it fails to file the annual return, it can violate the conditions for retaining dormant status.The ROC can take steps to revoke the company's dormant status and treat it as an active company.
- ROC Inquiry and Regulatory Action: Under Rule 8(4) of the Companies (Miscellaneous) Rules, 2014, the ROC can initiate an inquiry if it has reasonable grounds to believe that a dormant company is carrying on unauthorised business activities or conducting significant accounting transactions.
- Penalties and Directors' Disqualification: Failure to complete statutory filings or follow Board Meeting requirements can result in monetary penalties for the company and its officers in default. Repeated or continuing defaults can also create problems for directors. In certain circumstances, director disqualification can arise under Section 164(2) of the Companies Act, 2013.
- Strike-Off After Five Consecutive Years: Under Section 455(6), a company can remain dormant for a maximum of five consecutive years. If it does not apply to return to active status or take the appropriate steps for closure within this period, the ROC can initiate proceedings to remove its name from the Register of Companies under Section 248.
Recommended Reading
- ROC Compliance For Private Limited Company In India
- What Happens If A Company Misses MCA Filings?
- Can A Company Be Struck Off For Non-Compliance?
Conclusion
The main difference between a dormant and an active company is its legal status and permitted activities. An active company can carry on regular business, while a dormant company must follow restrictions and simplified compliance rules. Businesses should choose dormant status only when they intend to retain the company for future use.
Disclaimer: This blog is for informational purposes only. If you require legal consultation, kindly contact an experienced Corporate Lawyer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1. Is a dormant company legally different from an inactive company?
Yes. An inactive company is a company that meets the relevant inactivity conditions described under Section 455. A dormant company, on the other hand, is an entity that has formally applied for dormant status and received approval from the ROC.
Q2. Does a dormant company need to file annual returns?
Yes. It must file Form MSC-3 within 30 days from the end of each financial year, along with the required audited financial information. It does not follow the regular annual filing process applicable to active companies, such as filing AOC-4 and MGT-7, as described in the dormant-company framework.
Q3. Can a dormant company own assets and intellectual property?
Yes. Holding assets and intellectual property for future use is one of the main reasons a company can apply for dormant status. It can continue to hold property, equipment, patents, trademarks, copyrights, and software code, provided it follows the applicable conditions.
Q4. Can a dormant company have a bank account?
Yes. A dormant company can maintain a bank account for permitted expenses, such as ROC fees, statutory payments, and registered office maintenance. However, it should not use the account for regular commercial transactions or business revenue.
Q5. Does a dormant company need to appoint an auditor?
A dormant company must meet the applicable accounting and audit requirements. The financial information accompanying Form MSC-3 must be certified as required under the rules. The company should not assume that dormant status removes every responsibility relating to financial records or audit certification.