Talk to a lawyer @499

Know The Law

Right To Freedom of Religion

Feature Image for the blog - Right To Freedom of Religion

One of the fundamental human rights that is acknowledged by all countries and protected by numerous international and national legal frameworks is the freedom of religion. It embodies the idea that everyone has the right to practice express and modify their religion or beliefs without hindrance or prejudice. Ensuring a pluralistic and inclusive society that allows for the peaceful coexistence of diverse religious traditions is contingent upon the preservation of this right. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) are two important international documents that outline the right to freedom of religion.

What Is the Right To Freedom Of Religion?

The freedom to alter one religion or belief as well as the freedom to express it through instruction practice worship and observance are all included in this right. In a similar vein, Article 18 of the ICCPR restates these liberties and stresses that no one may be subjected to coercion that would restrict their ability to practice or follow any religion or belief of their choosing. The freedom of religion is frequently protected by constitutional provisions in democracies. For example, in the US the First Amendment of the Constitution forbids the government from establishing any religion and ensures the free exercise of religion. This twofold defence keeps the state from endorsing or promoting any specific religious doctrine while also guaranteeing that people can freely practice their religion.

Articles 25 through 28 of the Indian Constitution guarantee the right to freedom of religion in China. Subject to public order morality and health Article 25 guarantees every person the freedom of conscience as well as the freedom to openly declare practice and spread their religion. This article emphasizes how diverse religions and belief systems can coexist in Indian society due to its inclusive nature. Articles 26 27 and 28 go into further detail regarding the freedom from paying taxes to support any specific religion the rights of religious denominations and the right of educational institutions to teach religion. But some restrictions might apply and the freedom of religion is not unqualified. These restrictions are frequently put in place to safeguard the general public safety law and order health or other people's fundamental liberties. For example, it is forbidden to engage in religious rituals that cause harm to others such as human sacrifice or destructive customs. In addition, governments have the authority to step in and stop hate speech and violent incitement that passes for religious freedom.

Notwithstanding these safeguards, there are obstacles to the freedom of religion everywhere. Religious minorities frequently face violence persecution and discrimination. Religious freedom is undermined in certain nations by strict laws that limit religious practices and conversions. International human rights organizations and activists are vital in drawing attention to abuses and promoting the defence of religious freedom in such situations. A tolerant and diverse society must be promoted and this requires the freedom of religion. It fosters respect and understanding between various religious communities lets people explore and express their spirituality and enriches societies culturally. To guarantee that everyone can freely and safely follow their beliefs governments civil society and individuals must uphold this right with unwavering vigilance and commitment.

Constitutional Provisions

A fundamental component of democratic societies is the freedom of religion which permits people to freely practice express and disseminate their religious views. The Indian Constitution contains several articles that provide comprehensive protection for this right. Articles 25 to 28 in particular establish a framework that strikes a balance between secularism and public order as well as religious freedom.

Article 25

Article 25 of the Indian Constitution guarantees the freedom of conscience, allowing individuals to think and believe freely.

  • Freedom to Practice Religion: It ensures the right to openly practice, profess, and propagate any religion of one's choice.
  • Emphasis on Open-Minded Society: This article reflects the openness of Indian society, which permits individuals to follow any religion they choose.
  • Covers Religious Acts: The rights include not only personal religious beliefs but also acts of worship, rituals, and the proclamation of religious doctrines.
  • Conditional Rights: These rights are not absolute and are subject to considerations of public health, morality, and order.
  • State Regulation: The state has the authority to regulate religious practices that may harm others or disturb public peace.

Article 26

Article 26 grants religious denominations the autonomy to manage their own religious affairs.

  • Founding and Running Institutions: It includes the right to establish and operate institutions for religious and philanthropic purposes.
  • Management of Property: Religious groups can own, acquire, and manage real estate in accordance with the law.
  • Independent Functioning: The article ensures that religious communities can function independently and maintain their customs and practices.
  • Regulation by State: The state may impose regulations to ensure that religious activities respect morality, public health, and public order.

Article 27

Article 27 stipulates that no one is required to pay taxes specifically designated to support or sustain a particular religion or religious denomination.

  • Secular State Preservation: This clause is crucial for maintaining the secular nature of the state.
  • Prevention of Preferential Treatment: It ensures that no religion receives preferential treatment through public funds.
  • Public Funds Allocation: The article reflects the principle that public funds should not be used for religious purposes.

Article 28

Article 28 addresses the freedom to receive religious instruction or attend places of worship within educational institutions.

  • State-Funded Institutions: It prohibits educational institutions fully funded by the state from offering religious instruction.
  • Religious Community Institutions: It allows religious instruction in institutions managed by religious communities or those established by endowments or trusts that require such instruction.
  • Balance Between Rights: The clause balances the right of religious communities to provide religious education with the need for secular education.
  • Respect for Religious Diversity: Together with other constitutional clauses, Article 28 helps ensure respect for religious diversity and promotes harmony among various religions.
  • Framework for Religious Freedom: It provides a framework for exercising religious freedoms while ensuring actions respect morality, public order, and the rights of others.

Notwithstanding, there are certain obstacles in the way of executing these provisions. Sometimes religious disagreements and tensions occur putting these constitutional protections to the test. To handle complicated situations where religious freedom collides with other fundamental rights and societal interests the judiciary is essential in interpreting these articles. The Indian Constitution seeks to strike a careful balance between safeguarding individual liberties and maintaining social harmony by upholding these provisions.

Scope And Limitation

Unhindered religious practice expression and propagation are all made possible by the fundamental human right to freedom of religion. This freedom is guaranteed by numerous constitutions around the world such as the Indian Constitution which upholds it in Articles 25 through 28. Conscience freedom the freedom to declare practice and spread one's religion and the autonomy of religious organizations to run their affairs are all included in this sphere of rights. The freedom of religion does however have some restrictions and is not unqualified. These restrictions are required to uphold morality public health and order as well as to safeguard other people's fundamental rights. For example, it is forbidden to engage in religious rituals that cause harm to others such as human sacrifice or physical harm. Regulations that disturb the peace or break laws intended to further the interests of the public can also be enforced by the state.

Furthermore, although people are free to share their religion with others this freedom does not extend to the right to convert people against their will. Public schools that receive full state funding are not allowed to teach religion maintaining public education's secular character. As a result, even though the freedom of religion has a wide range of applications it is restrained to maintain social harmony and the defence of other fundamental rights.

Historical Context

The right to religious freedom has a long history and has changed dramatically over the centuries. Religious freedom was frequently restricted in ancient cultures when dissenters were frequently persecuted and state-imposed religions were prevalent. For instance until the Edict of Milan in 313 AD which established religious tolerance Christians in ancient Rome suffered greatly from persecution.

During Europe's Enlightenment the idea of religious freedom became more popular as thinkers like John Locke argued for the preservation of individual religious freedom and the separation of church and state. The acceptance of religious tolerance as a necessary component of human liberty began to change during this time. India has a rich historical background influenced by a diverse religious landscape that upholds the right to freedom of religion. While Buddhism and Jainism coexisted with Christianity and Islam later ancient Indian society was predominately Hindu.

Throughout the 16th century, the Mughal Emperor Akbar is remembered for his efforts to promote interfaith understanding and his policy of religious tolerance. There were obstacles to religious freedom during the British colonial era including laws that occasionally made religious conflicts worse. Fundamental values of secularism and religious tolerance were highlighted by the Indian freedom movement which was spearheaded by individuals such as Mahatma Gandhi. The Indian Constitution framers took inspiration from this historical legacy when they incorporated the right to freedom of religion in Articles 25 through 28 guaranteeing a secular state that upholds and preserves religious diversity.

The interpretation and application of the right to freedom of religion have been profoundly influenced by the decisions rendered by the Supreme Court of India in several historic cases.

  • Shirur Mutt Case (1954): In this instance the Supreme Court ruled that all rites and customs essential to a religion are included in the definition of religion. The court decided that unless religious practices endangered public order morality or health the state could not get involved. With a focus on the independence of religious groups in running their affairs, this ruling offered a broad interpretation of religious freedom.
  • Sardar Syedna Taher Saifuddin Saheb v. State of Bombay (1962): In an attempt to limit the authority of religious leaders to excommunicate members the Bombay Prevention of Excommunication Act 1949 was overturned by the Supreme Court. The Act infringed upon religious denominations' autonomy to administer their affairs the court declared. The protection of private religious practices from governmental interference was upheld in this case.
  • Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala (1986): Three Jehovah's Witness students who were expelled for not wanting to sing the national anthem due to their religious convictions won their case in court. The Supreme Court affirmed people's freedom of conscience and religion ruling that no one can be forced to sing the national anthem against their religious beliefs.
  • Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975): Even though it was mainly an electoral malpractice case religious freedom was greatly affected. The court restated the fundamental ideas that religious freedom is conditioned by public health morality and order and that the state should uphold secularism.

Challenges And Controversies

Worldwide there are many obstacles and disputes surrounding the right to freedom of religion many of which are caused by the intricate interactions between religious convictions and secular government. Conflicts between laws intended to further the public good like those pertaining to gender equality health regulations and religious practices present a serious obstacle. Moral and legal quandaries arise for example from practices such as child marriage and medical treatment refusal motivated by religion. Major issues that still exist are discrimination and religious intolerance.

The freedom of minority religious groups to freely practice their faith is regularly violated by persecution hate crimes and social exclusion. Blasphemy and anti-conversion laws are additional restrictions on religious freedom in certain areas and they are frequently abused to target minority communities. The challenges in India have become more intense due to the rise of religious nationalism. The conflict between religious freedom and majoritarian forces is exemplified by debates surrounding the lynching of people suspected of religious transgressions and the prohibition of religious clothing such as the hijab in educational institutions.

Furthermore, discussions regarding the boundaries of religious propagation have been triggered by the application of anti-conversion laws to limit proselytization. Due to these difficulties maintaining religious practices while making sure they don't violate the rights or welfare of others requires a careful balance. Ensuring religious freedom necessitates the diligent defence of minority rights strong legal precedents and continuous communication between various religious and secular viewpoints

Concept Of Secularism And Its Relationship With Religious Freedom

Secularism is the idea that religion and the state should be kept apart so that laws and government agencies are free from religious influence. This idea encourages religious neutrality enabling people to follow their faith without intervention or support from the government. By promoting an inclusive society where people of different beliefs coexist peacefully secularism seeks to level the playing field for all religions.

Secularism is essential to preserving people's freedom to practice and share their faith in terms of religious freedom. Secularism makes sure that no one religion dominates public life and that religious minorities are shielded from persecution by forbidding the state from favouring or discriminating against any religion. Since every citizen is treated equally regardless of their religious affiliation this separation helps to lessen religious conflicts and foster social harmony.

Fundamental human rights like the freedom of speech expression and assembly are likewise supported by secularism. It guarantees that morality and reason not religious dogma serve as the foundation for laws and policies. Secularism is not always applied uniformly around the world and conflicts can occur when defining its bounds, particularly in multicultural communities.

Secularism offers the essential framework for the just and equal practice of various religious beliefs within a pluralistic society hence secularism and religious freedom are generally interdependent.

Importance Of Interfaith Dialogue And Harmony In India

India a nation known for its religious diversity depends heavily on interfaith harmony and communication for its social fabric. Promoting mutual understanding and respect amongst various religious communities is crucial for preserving peace and unity in the face of the coexistence of multiple faiths including Hinduism Islam Christianity Sikhism Buddhism and Jainism.
 

Opening up communication and removing preconceptions and misconceptions are two benefits of interfaith dialogue. Such conversations prevent conflicts and promote a culture of coexistence by encouraging respect and understanding for one another. They uphold the virtues of empathy and tolerance by encouraging people to value differences in viewpoints and discover points of agreement. Given the historical and current occurrences of religious conflicts in India, interfaith harmony is especially crucial.

Community gatherings educational initiatives and cooperative social projects all of which foster interfaith communication help close gaps between various communities. These initiatives are essential for deterring violence and promoting a sense of patriotism.
 

Furthermore, the democratic and secular ideals enshrined in the Indian Constitution are supported by interfaith harmony. It guarantees that rather than causing conflict religious variety is celebrated. Interfaith discussion builds Indian society's social cohesion and resilience by highlighting shared values and well-being as a group opening the door to a more accepting and peaceful future.

Conclusion

To summarize India's commitment to pluralism and secularism is reflected in Articles 25 to 28 of the Indian Constitution which offer a strong foundation for the right to religious freedom. They guarantee the freedom of people to practice their religion while upholding an inclusive and peaceful community.